Misplaced Identity

I do believe that events in our lives have a significant effect on our personalities (a set of traits we display throughout our lives) and subsequently, the choices we make which forms our identity. There are those who spend their lives living for others – pleasers/givers – who never took the time to find out about themselves. There are those who believe the world revolves around them – narcissist/takers – whose sole purpose is about them. There are the rest of us who fall on the spectrum between the both.

For the last few months, I saw a recurring theme in my life and few others. I recognized that no matter how much we think we know ourselves, at times, we misplace our identities when we become desperate and in need of something we want. What I mean by this is I saw a woman who professed to have strong Christian beliefs become disparaging and demeaning of anyone very easily because she is experiencing work  burnout. I heard a conservative single person accept suggestive behaviors from someone who is considered newly married with a young family and professed love for spouse. I see compromise of long held values bent to fit a desire. I see loss of self-respect due to fear of the unknown. I see a willingness to compromise on things that will not be healthy in the long term. I see putting one’s better judgment aside to cater to someone else’s selfishness. I see the wearing down of time which makes people go soft on things that would not have been tolerated.

In life we want the perfect everything. We want a perfect God, perfect families, perfect spouses, perfect children, perfect friends, perfect jobs etc. Please don’t lie to yourself if you say you don’t want perfection. However, we know there is nothing on this earth that is perfect. So, when we are saddled with less than sublime contentment, our views and behaviors deteriorate over time. We go after or accept people and situations that require us to put aside or modify our values and beliefs. This pushes us to make less than ideal choices with a short-sighted view of a moment in the rest of our lives. We misplace our identities.

How many times have we read/watched a news story and someone always says “[he/she] was a good person. [he/she] would never have done….” For Christians, David was a good boy who turned into God’s champion; however, this was the same man who arranged a murder and engaged in infidelity. Judas was one of Jesus’ 12 and he was chosen because he had a consistently good character like the others but allowed himself to be bribed by money. Samson’s strength came from his beliefs which manifested in not cutting his hair; however, he compromised for love and companionship. The Bible and real life are filled with people misplacing their identities in a short-sighted compromising view in order to find a piece/peace that was missing at that moment in time.

We all want to feel whole -emotionally, physically, psychologically and spiritually. We all want to wake up every morning and truly thank God without asking for anything. However, for the majority of this broken world, we wake up and say a prayer of thanks along with a request or two. Some requests have been years in the asking and others are from recent overwhelming stressors. Whatever the situation, a feeling of desperation, urgency or last resort, can reek havoc on the identities we have carefully crafted to give us strength which are grounded by certain values and beliefs.

Do not be fooled. We all know or have that gut discomfort when we stray from ourselves. We know something is wrong but we are not always ready to face it or fix it until we find our confidence in our identities again. Life is not fair buttercups and sometimes it hands us and we accept a bag of sh*t (that may or may not explode). In reaction, we compromise or stray from what we hold dear because we truly believe this is the best way to feel in control. It’s that accumulated moment of weakness, desperation, frustration, longing, tiredness, impatience, out of ideas, dissatisfaction, disappointment, disillusionment etc that can be powerful. So powerful, we forget who we are, what we belief,  and what we are about. We forget our identities; we forget ourselves.

The bottom line is people make mistakes and err in behaviors. Sometimes we identify it quickly and sometimes we make it drag on for years. However, there is something liberating when you find your identity again and put yourself back on track. There is something freeing – our stomachs aren’t in knots, our minds aren’t constantly preoccupied, we aren’t always uneasy – that happens when we make those changes. This is not always easy because it means we have to undo a situation or take responsibility for uncharacteristic behaviors. When we remove the *cognitive dissonance, then our minds, bodies, beliefs and behaviors are in sync again. Life is a series of ups and downs and we all have our weak moments. We all have lost a bit of our identities in the past, currently and will in the future. However, its only tragic when we allow ourselves to be defeated and stay defeated. To err is human and you know what else is human? To change,  to recognize and acknowledge that we make less than great choices in a state of defeat but we can still find and reinstate our misplaced identities.

*cognitive dissonance (partial definition): mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual performs an action that is contradictory to one or more beliefs, ideas or values.



7 thoughts on “Misplaced Identity

  1. I think that many of us never had an identity to misplace or lose. From our birth, we were known by who are parents were, and later on, by our positions, roles, achievements, etc.

    Consider the implications of the following introductions:

    “This is our son, Steve”, or “This is Steve, our son”.

    “This is our Safety Officer, Steve”, or “This is Steve, our Safety Officer”.

    In the first of those introductions, relationship or role was placed ahead of person-hood, while in the 2nd set of introductions, person-hood was placed ahead of relationship or role. As long as that “what” of our identity can be stripped-away, we can become without a personal identity to fall-back on, but once we gain our own personal identity, regardless of what we gain or lose in relationships, roles, etc, we are still secure in our identity.

    I went through a huge identity-crisis in 2013, because all my “whats” had been stripped away and I didn’t have a “who” to fall-back on. That was a very traumatic time in my life, but it led me to gain a true sense of who I am: I am created in God’s image, which gives me incredible dignity, and I am a child of the living God, and nothing can strip that away from me.



    1. Steve,
      I agree that there are many who have not identify themselves because they are lost in someone else’s view of them. Those are the ones who are in the greatest danger of being misused by others or easily swayed.

      Even Christians can fall to the identity crisis at times. Even though they recognize themselves as children of God (which is a general view), they may falter with specific core foundational beliefs and behaviors when faced with repeated stressors. The weakness is in all of us and we may stumble, struggle or fall at any given moment. However, it is easier to regain ourselves when we know our foundation.

      1. Foundational to our identity as God’s children must be a sound, Biblical understanding of God. If God has be presented as the stern lawgiver and judge, we are afraid to go to Him with our problems because we are afraid of how He may react. That often results from an authoritarian and legalistic upbringing, like I had. However, if our understanding of God is as our Heavenly Father, yes, we may get a “whipping” once in a while, but we know that God loves us more than we could even imagine. Pastor Corteze was fond of saying “If God has a refrigerator, YOUR pictures are plastered all over it.” If we are secure in who we are as God’s children, it will be much easier for us to weather the storms of life because we know that God is our ever-faithful Helper and Guide. We also know that He hears our cries for help.

        My journey has been hard and rocky, but I am becoming more and more secure in the knowledge that God will never leave me nor forsake me. I am becoming “Steve”, and God is adding on the “extras” as He sees fit. One of the “extras” He has added-on is “Pastor”, and even though I am constantly-amazed that God could use someone like me, I give Him all the honor and glory for what he is doing through me. This is an exciting time in my life.

          1. I didn’t go looking for it, and I certainly didn’t ask for it, but our all-wise God dropped it into my lap and said “Run with it”. I have had several opportunities to come alongside someone who was hurting with understanding, caring and compassion, and apply the Salve of the Gospel to their hurting heart and soul. Yes, my experiences, as difficult as they have been, have helped prepare me to minister to others.


Tell Me What You Think

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s